Originally Posted by
gigaschatten
And what makes you so sure?
Most people can't visualize a rotating cube. What makes you think your mind develops visualization superpowers when asleep so you can imagine a seemingly unlimited amount of personalities and places?
Can you prove that dreams are imagination? What is the evidence?
Is waking reality on the other hand no imagination, just because your influence on matter is a bit more limited?
What if dreaming is caused by the invisible part of your existence being temporarily unattached to your body? Most things we deal with every day can not be seen and scientists even assume that 22% of our universe consists of dark (unperceivable) matter and another 74% of dark energy. That leaves 4% of perceivable matter/energy in our whole universe from which we have directly and indirectly maybe perceived 0,05% or less. You really think we can derive from that how our universe works? Consider that.
Your argumentation stands on brittle ground but you may not realize that because it is what is commonly accepted in your culture. Remember though that acceptance does not equal accuracy and that society is rather an amplifier than a filter for misleading beliefs.
You can't answer my question, but I'm eager to hear your opinion, YOUR opinion, not what you have been taught and now think is yours.
Even in the unlikely case that you are right and DCs are a fragment of our imagination, don't we often fool or lie to ourselves when we want to forget, when we want something to be true badly, when we have insufficient or wrong information, when we cannot or do not want to deal with something, ...? So what makes you think even if DCs are a part of your mind, that they would speak the truth as they know it?
I'm still not out of arguments. Do you have control over your mind? I see people regularly give up because they think they can't go on. I see people that are unhappy, because their mind does not realize what they really have. I see people with eating disorders, because they cannot accept their body and I see people that break out with aggression because they cannot control their ego. So what makes you think we could control a whole personality - and if you leave them some space, you will notice that DCs can have complex personalities that are very different from your own - just because it is part of our mind? Do we even have control over our mind or does it control us?
Have you ever experienced (unlikely) or read about experiences people made with DMT? (recommended literature: "DMT - The Spirit Molecule") There is more than one dimension of reality and the physical body is neither you nor the cause of your existence. Sleep is one of the closest things to death that we can experience without permanently giving up the physical body. Use it to learn and expand your horizon or go on believing the narrow view of a culture that worships physical matter. You decide.
You see, I have good reasons to believe what I do and I am sure you have yours, but it can be very enlightening to recheck them.