Transforming into a frockin pegasus-unicorn tonight and sensing emotions while galloping into space. My teammates will ride on my back, and will rain holy hell on some enemy DCs. Got this shit.
Correction: in a few nights ;-)
Printable View
Transforming into a frockin pegasus-unicorn tonight and sensing emotions while galloping into space. My teammates will ride on my back, and will rain holy hell on some enemy DCs. Got this shit.
Correction: in a few nights ;-)
If you have one lucid remembered then it's 5 points or 5 points + 1 points for remembered dream?
and why are those points left out in the tier 3?
*WBTB fail (no lucid after WBTB) - 1 point
*WBTB success (lucid after WBTB) - 3 points
*Do a successful Reality Check - 1 point
*Unsuccessfully stabilize the dream - 1 point
*Successfully stabilize the dream - 2 points
*Interact with a Dream Character - 2 points
For example wbtb is really essential and difficult even for experienced oneironaut. I don't see the point of skipping these points at all, au contraire, these activities are crucial and should be appropriately valued.
Nfri
5 points total.
Because I believe that tier 3 being who they are supposed to be, already have their.technique down, so if that involves or doesn't involve WBTB I don't want to favor one. Also some of them never stabilize or RC in a traditional sense. I (for instance) check the stabilty of the dream and raise it only if needed. So at this point it becomes personal preferance to RC or stabilize. Also, if it is too unstable, lots might just say "screw it" and DEILD. Interact with DC, most people in tier 3 have had their LDs "even out" a bit. Some people for instance never ever see DCs in lucids (note summoning DC still counts as points if they want a DC). Others have evened out the oposite wayand always see DCs. Interacting with certain DCs will even get them lucid. Hope this makes sense. :)
Everyone!
Don't forget
Personal task
Put an item in the SAO menu and take it out in a different dream.
3 step task
Gravity
Teleport
Element manipulation
I just imagined some would make the personal goal easy for themselves to get easy points. But, since they can only complete one personal goal for points that doesn't really matter.
Anyway, my 3 step tasks are:
Fully move through big solid object
Teleport
Full Transformation
Personal task:
Fully transform into another animal
Depending on what it is, and who it is. The only rule with personal goal is that it has to be something that you haven't done before. It should work for all levels since someone just beginning could put "eat something" as a personal, but someone like me and you will have to find something we haven't done.
My 3 step task:
Push Hand through solid object
Fully move through big solid object
Partial Transformation
Personal Task:
At least partially transform into a feline
I guess a full transformation gives only 10 points and not an extra 4 points for partial transformation. But it would count for my 3 step task, right?
You put a lot of work and thought into this and it is much appreciated Sensei!! :)
I will think about my 3 steps and personal and post them before the start date. I appreciate having this platform to further improve my skills, learn new things and the fun we have reading each others achievements. One comment, and it is not a big issue, is that the scoring does seem to promote DEILDing over any other method (slightly more than previous competitions). A participant may not have as much of an incentive (related to points/competition) to stay in what may be a wonderful lucid dream if you have already achieved 20 points (and either already did the bonus tasks previously or can't remember the bonus tasks). I am not sure what the solution is without raising the maximum points above 20, and again, I will go along with the way it is either way and be happy of course! :) I am excited about the new elements to the competition as well! :)
By the way, which one is this?/what is SAO? - "Put an item in the SAO menu and take it out in a different dream. "
3 step task:
time control
elemental manipulation
change gravity
personal task:
completely eat an entire person
Are DEILD-chain dream points limited to 20 now instead of 10?
I think the promotion of DEILD is fine, since the ability to produce a DEILD chain seems to me to be the pinnacle of LDing. It can be sort of hard though to determine just what is a DEILD: were you really awake or was it a FA? Did you maintain consciousness all the way into the dream or did you just DILD? But I don't worry about these little details: if I can finish a dream (lucid or non-lucid) and consistently enter a string of LDs afterwards, I'd be ecstatic.
My 3-step (I guess we're putting them here instead of the official thread?):
1) interact with a DC
2) basic summon
3) fly
Personal task: teleport without landing in the void.
I think it's fine for tier 3 to not have points for really basic things, that's the tier to really push one's boundaries.
Yeah, am I reading it right that a 5-link DEILD chain gets you the same points as 5 separate DILDs? :oQuote:
Originally Posted by fogelbise
You know, I've actually found it to be the opposite. If I'm having to DEILD from one LD to the next, it's usually because I didn't get great stability out of the dream.
That's why I personally count a lucid chain as a single LD rather than a bunch of separate LDs. IMO, it's really just one lucid that was unfortunately chopped up into pieces but then saved by DEILDing. If I can, I strongly prefer to have one long LD or just move through the void without leaving the dream at all.
Well when you put it like that I agree. Sure, I'd rather have 90-minute solid vivid fully-aware epic LDs all night long every night, but I'll take DEILDs any day instead of just waking up.
Hmmm... My deilds are rarely like that anymore. They are long anf powerful. Haha
I am totally with Canis on this one. I can stay in LDs for a long time and get a lot done, and generally I will not attempt a DEILD if I've had a successful LD because I'd rather write in my DJ about all the amazing things I just did.
Sometimes when I DEILD, I forget parts of the previous dream(s) because they are taken over by new dream memories.
I think I will really struggle to keep up with the DEILDers with this point system, even if my LDs are extremely stable with strong dream control.
Can we meet halfway? I'll try to think of an alternative solution.
I'm mostly happy with the points though, and I'll have a think about my 3-step and personal goal.
Thanks for putting this together, Sensei!
I definitely see where yall are coming from. I have had many DEILD chains that were only DEILD because of the instability. I wouldn't want to give points to instability over experience. Yall wanna talk about this elsewhere and see if we can come up with something.
Yeah, I use DEILD almost exclusively to make up for previous instability.
Maybe we could do a group Skype chat when CL is free later.
Thanks for including the Lucid Dares, btw, that's awesome! :D
I'm really excited about all the tasks, this is going to be a lot of fun!
I agree about the DEILD thing - it would motivate to DEILD away like the devil on the cost of quality - even while I don't think, many would do it such.
And I'd also like to know what you mean by SAO menu?
Another thing - will you open a separate thread with the stuff all in the first post for easy lookings ups?
Lots of thoughts and effort went into this, obviously - thank you again - lets kick it off! :wink:
http://i1339.photobucket.com/albums/...ps1d1147ac.jpg
DEILDing is a part of the big picture of LDing, I don't think it should be removed entirely. It is a successful "get lucid" event and as such it should carry points. Turning it around, let's say someone is skilled at DEILDing and less skilled at long, stable dreams, why shouldn't one be able to gather points the way that they're good at? I think it's pretty clear that stability, goal memory, and control will win out even over DEILDs the way they are. You'd have to get 4 DEILDs in a chain with no control to match a single maxed out from control LD.
Don't think this is really an issue?
I'm not an interested party since I've never really DEILDed and certainly never chained.
So is there an official rules post? Start date? Sorry I don't have time to dig past all the other nonsense posted here.
http://www.dreamviews.com/general-lu...ml#post2114350
Soon to be updated though, we're discussing now. Maybe best to check back later, I'll leave you a message when it's ready.
Edit: Oh, speedy work, FryingMan! haha
Just feel I need to say this -- while DEILDing Is generally not that difficult -- especially coming out of a prematurely-ended LD -- there is always a chance that the dreamer will lose lucidity if they DEILD into a false awakening. There should be something given for successfully DEILDing, but I am fairly certain I could jiggle my WL body a bit to wake up, and then have a silly long DeILD chain. I would not really want to do that, as it feels a bit cheap, but it's the possibility.
Also, I will update my personal task chain very soon. Just need to ponder a bit . . . :)
I didn't think this through, Fryingman - too lazy - some sort of a middle way would be good - maybe it's good already - I'll have to study the whole thing more in depth...
And Xanous - I guess there will be a new thread for the comp with the rules and teams and whatnot in the first post - here you go for what he pre-posted: