 Originally Posted by cmind
I have two things to say to that: First, most people are addicted to several drugs, but they don't know it because the addiction is socially accepted. Caffeine addiction. Alcohol addiction. Codeine addiction (Tylenol). Also, a lack of something as simple as regular exercise can have a huge effect on mood.
Second, I know from experience that depression can alter memories in subtle ways. The depressed person might believe that they've always felt this way, even when they haven't. Unless you keep an actual journal or something equally as concrete, you don't really know what your emotional state was a month before you first started the meds, versus a month after. Even the meds themselves can alter memory. This isn't SSRI-specific, but I can tell you that there was about a 4 month period when I was addicted to doctor-prescribed (prescribed dosage) benzos, and that entire 4 month period of my life was basically wiped from memory until about a year later when I finally got those memories back. Now, this is just an anecdote, but it demonstrates that drugs can alter your memory, especially something as ephemeral as remembered emotional states.
So bottom line: I don't believe you when you say you felt like shit when you weren't taking drugs.
The statement "drugs can alter your memory" is terribly broad. Yes, I'd have to agree with this statement, who wouldn't? Of course some drugs can alter your memory or cause amnesia. Funny, a group of drugs known as benzodiazepines are notorious for such a thing. I'm just going to say right now that, if all you were on were benzos, then it is not fair for you to make a judgment on anti-depressants. That's like comparing apples to oranges. Yes they're both fruit, but they aren't the same thing. It isn't hard to make a comparison when being purposefully broad. Chemicals are chemicals man, chemicals can kill you! Better not breathe, eat, or continue to live or the chemicals will do it for you.
From wiki, "Benzodiazepines enhance the effect of the neurotransmitter gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), which results in sedative, hypnotic (sleep-inducing), anxiolytic (anti-anxiety), anticonvulsant, muscle relaxant and amnesic action." From wiki on anti-depressants, " Drugs including the monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs), tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs), tetracyclic antidepressants (TeCAs), selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), and serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) are most commonly associated with the term."
These drugs have entirely different modes of action. What makes you think they're all the same? Benzodiazepines work with GABA neurotransmitters, like alcohol. Anti-depressants mainly deal with serotonin, dopamine, and norepinepherine. Some anti-depressants, like Wellbutrin or Stratterra, are used to treat ADHD because it reduces impulsiveness, improves concentration and memory, and stabilizes emotions (ADHD and depression are correlated, to a degree). So tell me, how is a drug that improves concentration going to alter my memory or cause me to lose my memory altogether? One last quote from wiki on the antidepressant page, "Other medications that are not usually called antidepressants, including antipsychotics in low doses[3] and benzodiazepines,[4] may be used to manage depression, although benzodiazepines cause a physical dependence to form. Stopping benzodiazepine treatment abruptly can cause unpleasant withdrawal symptoms." It specifically mentioned benzos as having negative effects and causing physical dependence, but none others because everything right now is speculative. Benzos are known to have terrible effects. Look man, I'm sorry your doctor gave you benzos to treat depression, but you can't act as if benzodiazepines are the type of drug that you talk about when casually using the term "anti-depressant drug." You're making a purely speculative statement that, if action were taken on its behalf, would ruin the quality of life for many and destroy the opportunity for others.
Also, thanks, I appreciate that you know everything about me and my life and that I most likely didn't feel like shit at all. Just so you know, I have never been prescribed anti-depressants to treat depression. I started taking Wellbutrin XL a year and a half after overcoming depression as a medication to take in conjunction with (at the time) Vyvanse to treat ADD. My memory was never altered by a drug while depressed, maybe just by depression. Considering that "drugs can alter your memories", I don't think I believe you when you say you felt like shit on them or even before you started taking them. I mean, you were actually on a drug known for causing anterograde amnesia. Why, if you don't believe me (let's still assume that I was being treated for depression with Wellbutrin, as you seemed to have wrongfully believed was the case) because I was taking a drug that improves concentration, should anyone believe you and your anecdote when you couldn't even remember what happened the entire time you were on them?
|
|
Bookmarks