 Originally Posted by Universal Mind
The Hendrix solo I posted is what I think is the greatest display of musical talent there has ever been. It blows my mind. I have never come across a guitar solo that could even compete with it. I don't know whom exactly you are saying lists Hendrix just to be copy cats, but it is a fact the he impresses the Hell out of his fans. He really was a total badass.
I became a Hendrix fan twenty years ago. Since then, I have learned that the general consensus among classic rock musicians is that Hendrix is not only the best there has ever been but also hands down the greatest guitarist of all time without question. Neil Young said Hendrix is "absolutely the best guitar player that ever lived" and, "There is nobody even in the same building with that guy." Before Hendrix got famous, Eric Clapton acted really strange and asked Pete Townshend to walk into an uncrowded movie theater with him to talk. When they sat down, Clapton finally said what it was bout. He told Townshend that there was a guy who was about to put both of them out of business. Eric Clapton vanished from the music scene for a while because he felt so overshadowed by Jimi Hendrix. Roger Daltrey, the lead singer of The Who, said Hendrix is the greatest guitarist of all time. I don't think people say Hendrix is the greatest because all of those other people say he is the best or because so many of their friends and peers do. There is obviously something to the idea, and the fact that it is true has a lot of people noticing it.
I am more of a Beatles fan than a Hendrix fan. However, Hendrix was a much better guitar player than George Harrison. Though Jimi Hendrix could sing well and had good musicians playing with him, he (Experience, Band of Gypsies) was a very guitar centered musical act. The Beatles were phenomenal for a whole list of reasons.
By the way, make sure you see the Woodstock clip I posted. It might convince you.
I never disputed the fact that Hendrix was a good guitarist, i think he was an excellent guitarist, but just because he was one of the best of his time doesn't mean he is the best of all time. That rules out all other guitarists at the time and that is quite unfair since a lot of different artists were good in their own ways. Jimi Hendrix was good, he was recognized as a great guitarist, but if you compare his music to a lot that was being produced at the time, there was stuff coming out that was way more popular than Jimi's material.
Oh, and the improvisation he pulled off. Being a guitar player myself of the same style, i know that improvisations are easy once you get good at them. Most improvisations are off the top of the head, but i could tell that a lot of the material he had must have been practiced before. Notice how he divided it into sections, don't get me wrong, it WAS an improvisation, but a lot of it sounded like material and riffs he had played about with, then he just incorporated and improvised around them. He did pull some complex riffs and soloing out there, but its easy to replicate if you have a lot of good material to use when improvising. And lets face it, coming up with something complex that sounds good is fairly easy nowadays. I'm not saying i could do better, but i know for a fact that others out there could even back then. The advantage Jimi had was his moment of popularity, but to be honest, like a lot of artists back then, he too was short winded and didn't last too long in the mainstage area of the public eye.
I am beginning to dislike Jimi Hendrix because of the sheer fact that he is worshipped as the best guitarist ever, when in reality he is not. There are probably way better guitarists out there than Jimi Hendrix in terms of ability, because at the end of the day, the one thing Jimi did have was exclusivity and opportunity. Many people don't have that luxury, but if they did, i think Jimi would have been out-staged pretty quickly.
But though a large majority think that Jimi was the best guitarist of all time, that doesn't mean that he was the best guitarist of all time, consider all the guitar players out there now and the varying ability.
|
|
Bookmarks