While ranting on in the religion subforum - snoop asked, why I wouldn't engage in topics like this one - so here I am - not meant to be condescending - I just really believe, a bit of illumination could so some good around the place.
 Originally Posted by Ginsan
You guys are all doing it wrong. We should be asking our friend UdIe something much more interesting. How did he get to the conclusion that dream invasion is possible?
Exactely.
Neither is dream-sharing possible.
Like usual – I am well aware, I can't prove a negative – so I can’t prove that – but really – would you believe anything else, less desirable, if the situation would look equivalent?
So many people are trying it, and nothing worth any notice ever came of it.
A realistic person would take the lack of valid evidence in consideration - the fact that it is well known, that the human mind can conjure up all sorts of subjective experiences - we should definitively know this as LDers - that relying on one's subjective feeling is not a good idea.
People also seem to adapt their experiences, even if far removed, to fit into pre-existing schemata - and tada - everybody feels validated.
Ultimately there is always a cryptic medium involved, through which some completely unknown energy-form would travel to transmit the needed information.
Physicists would be seriously delighted, if one of those supposed psychic persons would reveal the pass to a Noble Prize and a new field of physics to them.
Nope – not happening.
What is also not happening, is that a pair of sharing dreamers gets the 1.000.000 Dollars, that the Randi-challenge promises to give out for water-tight proof.
Wishful thinking is the source of faith.
Then there (are) were people making stuff up in order to simply impress others and become interesting.
Some want for make money with books and whatnot and put sensationalist stuff out - goes for Castaneda as well.
And then there are the faithful people experiencing things, which seem vaguely indicative of what they really, really wish they could do - it being soo fascinating.
That’s where the whole excitement comes from.
Oh – and Inception of course and any other stuff, made mystical for driving sales up, and cater to the people who love to shudder a bit and keep their superstitions cosily at heart - who wants to die after all?!
gaah.gif (Got a bit of a temperament - can type myself into serious exasperation at times .. soz)
 Originally Posted by gab
Now now, let's play nice. Instead of name-calling, why don't we take this opportunity to educate everybody who stumbles upon this tread, what's the difference and why one is not so good and the other one is ok. 
How could there be a difference?
If it was possible to connect your mind from within the lucid dream on purpose – why shouldn’t it be possible to invade somebody’s dream?
It’s not as if there was any sort of manual how to do it, and security-measures being taken – nope – people seem to believe they can do it just like that – no problem.
Just to make sure – I believe, none of them are possible – and that on solid ground.
I could imagine, that it will actually one day be possible – but with the help of technology – something to really enable a connection from mind to mind – the old-fashioned way with electricity and radio or cables or whatnot – not wafting exotic yet to be found energy waves of some arcane frequency – or however the latest fad has it.
People supposedly show up in other people's dreams unexpectedly – if somebody was proficient in LDing and in actual "magic" - like The Cusp and others seem to have claimed in the past - piece of cake - same mechanism.
Another argument, why it's not bloody likely – we would see the fallout from that otherwise.
If it was possible – we’d see powertrips being played out and obviously, wouldn’t you think?
Seems people assume, only nice people could share dreams, and that the ether in some way would protect the nice lucid dreamers from the inevitable harm, that would follow, should their feats really be attainable.
Isn’t it interesting, how once the people claiming to do such feats quit doing that, or even quit posting – nobody seems to share dreams anymore – activity is way down in that department - so what is more likely - people bathing in other people's admiration - or - *insert insanity of the recent past*.
Seems in the moment, the willing members don’t get lucid in the first place. Shame that, sort of – or is there somebody willing to claim, they actively share dreams at the moment?
Come on everybody – a bit more sceptical thinking never hurts – and intellectual honesty is a virtue in my eyes – why delude oneself, even while deep down having the nagging feeling, that that’s what it is anyway?
|
|
Bookmarks