Thread: Lucid Dreams are illusions caused by jinns.

Originally Posted by dutchraptor

The question is does every muslim believe in the scientific explanation this guy tried to explain to us?.

The answer to that, I think, is probably a resounding "No."

And does every Muslim on the planet really believe in Jinns as described in this thread? Seems like a stretch to me...

Originally Posted by Sageous

The answer to that, I think, is probably a resounding "No."

And does every Muslim on the planet really believe in Jinns as described in this thread? Seems like a stretch to me...

Probably not all I said I think so and that is because I'm pretty sure all muslims I know and met believes in them. Could also be cultural. But since they're mentioned a lot in the qur'an it's not wrong to think a lot of muslims believe in them.

Originally Posted by daban

Probably not all I said I think so and that is because I'm pretty sure all muslims I know and met believes in them. Could also be cultural. But since they're mentioned a lot in the qur'an it's not wrong to think a lot of muslims believe in them.

Then don't give people flak saying it's not scientific. If he had said "I am a muslim and I believe that jinn are the cause of lucid dreams" and left it at that i would have respected his opinion. But since he went out and said that it's proven because of science which he obviously doesn't understand, people should be free to take exception to it.

Originally Posted by Ksero

Then don't give people flak saying it's not scientific. If he had said "I am a muslim and I believe that jinn are the cause of lucid dreams" and left it at that i would have respected his opinion. But since he went out and said that it's proven because of science which he obviously doesn't understand, people should be free to take exception to it.

Where did he say that his theory is proven by science? I can't find it. I only find him describing some scientific theory of conciousness existence without a physical form and that he thinks that's what OBE and AP's are.

In the Jinn part, he made this thread to ask people what their opinions were on his theory and he clearly says "I THINK". Which means, it is an opinion.

And what I wrote was not about jinns causing LDs. It was about Jinns existence in general.