Ahhhh the great "Is Psi Real?" debate. You'll have to excuse me ahead of time if I take a long time to reply... my life is pretty hectic, and I'm busy a lot. Nonetheless, I couldn't help but stick my nose in and throw a few ideas out there .
The quotes from hepennypacker52 in the original post will be displayed in itallics. My comments will be in normal text underneath.
Here's what I think about all of these "PSI abilities", from what I read (and wasted a part of my life) on yesterday :
You spent one day reading about psi abilities and have already concluded something? That's amazing, considering there are thousands of intelligent people dedicated to the field of figuring it out, that have spent their entire lives...
B) Now for a general statement about all of these magical things : it's bull. I do not know how all of you guys think that you actually can suck energy from the earth or sun and do things with it. It's just not possible, it's all in your head.
Ok this really isn't an argument... "it's fake because it's fake!". Of course, you do present right at the end that you think it's all in our heads. I agree that people must be careful when experimenting with things outside the scope of modern science, and they must be very skeptical. I also agree that a lot of people who believe in psychic things might be delusional, and it is probably all in their head. However - that does not mean EVERY person who believes in psychic topics is delusional.
There are ways to prove it isn't all in our head. For example, if I can make a warm psi ball, and throw it at a digital thermometer, and the reading on the thermometer goes up... wouldn't that be proof that SOMETHING is going on? Or what about the videos at PsiPog.net (not "PsiProg" ) of psychokinesis? Even if the videos are produced by "normal" means (which, in my opinion, they aren't), they still aren't in our heads. The objects definitly MOVE in the videos. While you might argue that they move via "normal" means is another topic all together - the point being, it isn't just "in our heads".
c) PSI balls? In your imagination. I wasted about 10 minutes of my life trying to make one, and I actually believed in it for that 10 minutes, and pictured myself "sucking" in energy from the sun, and then the earth. Well guess what, I saw nothing but air between my hands. People that think they see these things, it's in their head.
People have taken pictures of visible psi. And just because you can't do it in 10 minutes doesn't mean it's impossible. Don't you think you would need to spend a LITTLE more time before deciding whether it's real or not? Like the one member said earlier - if you tried to play the piano in 10 minutes, you would suck ass. But that doesn't mean it's impossible.
d) Astral projections? It's all in your head. You can imagine that you seperate yourself from your body, but it's just all your imagination. Why do you think people are confined to mental institutes? It's because their brain is telling them things that make them believe things that are not normal.
If you are serious about researching AP, I would highly recommend the book: Journeys Out of the Body by Robert Monroe. It's only like $10, and it's very scientific in nature. It explores the possibility of it being "all in our head" throughly.
e) Force fields? Ok, make a force field, and I'll come over and punch you in the face. We'll see how that works.
Force Bubbles have been used to stop forces greater than your punch. Again, you're not really presenting a logical argument here other than "man, they just can't be real!".
f) I went to PSIprog.net and read some of the articles, it's all just bull and I actually laughed at it. They say, "yes, you can create energy balls and use psychic powers to tell what number the dice will land on, but you're not going to do it every time". IT'S ALL PROBABILITY. If you say "the dice will land on 3" and it happens, that's because you had a 1/6 chance of doing it, and you actually hit that chance.
Yes, believe it or not we are aware of probability. In fact, all serious psi researchers are. Statistics and probability are used to PROVE psi exists, actually. For example, if you try to force a 3 on a die, and you roll it 100 times... probability says it will land on 3 about 16 or 17 times. Now what if you actually roll it 100 times and it comes up on 3 over 60 times. That is very significant. Things like standard deviation and z-score are used to determine if something paranormal has happened.
g) Just to have some fun, I tried the deck of cards thing. I took the ace of spades, and shuffled it in the deck. I removed 6 cards, shuffled some more, removed 6 cards, etc. I got down to about 10 cards until I hit the ace. I must have powers! Not. It's so funny how they say "yes, use the power to move this tiny shard of paper." Do you know how minute of a disturbance it takes to get a ultra-thin piece of paper to move? And you think your mind did that?
You addressed two topics here. The first is about the cards... That card game is actually pretty fun, and I've done it to the point of having the target card be the last card I turn over. That's actually not very likely, according to probability. Of course... things like that take more practice other than "hey, let me give this a shot, then when I fail I will have more evidence that psi is fake".
You also addressed the pinwheel. While I agree that there are people who aren't correctly preparing the pinwheel, and it is just moving by "normal" means... there are actually people out there that are more anal than you about minute disturbances, and dedicate a lot of time to remove every little disturbance - and then STILL move the pinwheel in the direction they are trying to. See Placebo's posts .
h) PSIprog also uses backup that makes it completely evident that they do not know what the hell they are talking about. They say, "sure, you may say this is impossible and the laws of physics prevent it, but what about time travel? People believe time travel exists, but that's not in physics..." Ok good statement, it's too bad that the laws of physics do not prevent time travel or negate it, but the laws to deny psychic powers, sorry.
While I agree that that argument is pretty weak, keep in mind I wrote it when I was 15 . The laws of physics don't really say psychic powers are impossible... In fact, research quantum physics and you'll find a lot of bizarre laws that you never thought modern science would support - for example, a particle being in two places at once, and phasing out of existance when not being observed.
i) Hmm, if these telekinetic powers are real, then why hasn't anybody gotten really good at it and taken over the word? I'm sure that of the thousands of people that waste their lives, at least a few of them should be so good at it that they can kill people with their PSI balls or mind power.
That's like saying "people can't bench press 100lbs, because if they could, they would just take over the world". You are exagerating the abilities, and then asserting that since your exagerated concept doesn't exist, then the original un-exagerated concept doesn't exist.
j) Please try and think about what you're doing, because it's just going to create a big waste of time for you. Start worrying about reality, not about spending your entire life "seperated in your spritual body in space", reality is what matters.
I agree that reality is what matters. Although you don't really provide any definition for reality other than "normal stuff that doesn't include psychic things". Perhaps you should be inspecting reality a little more closely?
k) If you choose to not listen to a word I say, well at least you can have fun with yourself for the rest of your life. When everybody labels you a psycho and ridicules you, you can just go live in an astral projection or something like that, at least you'll be at peace with yourself.
Actually, I thought that at first. But the more I open up to people about my strange obsession, the more people come to me with their own experiences, saying that they don't think it's strange at all, and they believe in what I say (at varying degrees). It's actually quite common for a person to have strange psychic experiences in their life. My one friend used to have a ghost in their house when she was little, and never really told anyone. My other friend has precognitive dreams, and never told anyone except her mother (who also has precognitive dreams). Another friend thought I was completely crazy... then tried to pinwheel exercise out of curiousity and succeeded... and then was freaked out .
My suggestion isn't that you immediately accept everything that I say and get obsessive about psychic abilities and practice hard every day to become this super master psychic. My suggestion would be: If you are going to invest some time in deciding whether this stuff is fake or not, invest a LITTLE more time than one day (if you're serious enough). Perhaps grab a book or two, do a little reading, try some exercises out... maybe spend one month checking it out. If after a month you don't get any results, and you still find it to be completely bull... then fair enough. At least you looked into it a little more than 10 minutes .
~Sean
Webmaster of PsiPog.net
|
|
Bookmarks